How to Vet a Gold IRA Dealer: A Complete Due-Diligence Checklist

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you open an account through one of them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our evaluation criteria, see our full disclosure policy for details.

Choosing a Gold IRA company is not like picking an online retailer. You’re trusting a company to handle a rollover from an existing retirement account, help you select IRS-approved metals, and coordinate secure storage for years or decades. A bad choice doesn’t just cost you a bad purchase, it can cost you thousands in unnecessary fees, or worse, land you in IRS trouble if metals aren’t IRA-eligible.

The good news: the signs of a trustworthy dealer are consistent and checkable. This guide walks through exactly what to look for before you commit.

Why Vetting Matters More With Gold IRAs Than Other Purchases

Gold IRA companies aren’t licensed the way stockbrokers or registered investment advisors are. Most operate as precious metals dealers who partner with a separate, IRS-approved custodian to hold your account and a separate depository to store your metal. That means you’re really evaluating three things at once: the dealer’s sales practices, the custodian’s track record, and the depository’s security. A dealer who’s vague about any one of these is worth a second look.

The Core Vetting Checklist

1. Better Business Bureau and Regulatory History

Start with the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and the Business Consumer Alliance (BCA). Look for:

• Accreditation length, a company accredited for 10+ years has weathered market cycles, not just a recent bull run in gold prices
• Rating, A+ is standard among established players; anything lower warrants a closer look at why
• Complaint patterns, a handful of complaints isn’t disqualifying, but check whether the company responded and resolved them, and whether complaints cluster around a specific issue (e.g., high-pressure sales calls, slow delivery, unclear fees)

Also check your state Attorney General’s consumer protection division and any public complaint databases for enforcement actions against the company. This step takes ten minutes and rules out the worst offenders immediately.

2. Fee Transparency

A trustworthy dealer publishes its fee structure or provides it clearly on request, before you’ve given any personal information. Watch for:

• Setup fees (typically $50–$100)
• Annual custodian fees (typically $75–$150)
• Storage fees, segregated storage (your metal stored separately) usually costs more than non-segregated (commingled) storage
• Markup over spot price, this is the least transparent fee in the industry. Ask directly: “What percentage over spot price will I pay on the specific coins or bars I’m buying?” A dealer who won’t give you a straight answer is a red flag.

If a company’s website has no fee information at all and directs you to “call for pricing,” that’s not automatically disqualifying, but you should press for exact numbers before signing anything.

3. The Sales Process Itself

Legitimate dealers educate before they sell. Warning signs during your first call or consultation:

• Pressure to “act today” because of a supposed limited-time bonus
• Reluctance to answer specific fee questions
• Pushing numismatic or “collectible” coins instead of standard IRA-eligible bullion (numismatic coins often carry high markups and are a common source of investor complaints)
• Vague or evasive answers about which custodian and depository they use

A good specialist will walk you through how a rollover works, what metals are IRS-eligible, and what your all-in costs look like, without rushing you toward a decision on the first call.

4. Custodian and Depository Transparency

Ask directly: “Which custodian administers the IRA, and which depository stores the metal?” Reputable dealers work with well-known, IRS-approved custodians (examples include Equity Trust, STRATA Trust, and GoldStar Trust) and established depositories (such as Delaware Depository or Brink’s Global Services). If a dealer is cagey about naming these partners, that’s a serious red flag, since it’s your money sitting with that custodian, not the dealer.

5. Buyback Policy

Ask what happens when you want to sell. A dealer with a clear, published buyback policy, ideally without excessive fees or unreasonable delays, is signaling confidence in its own pricing. Get this in writing, not just verbally promised.

6. IRS Compliance on Metal Types

Only specific gold, silver, platinum, and palladium products meet IRS purity and origin requirements for IRA inclusion (for example, gold must generally be .995+ pure, with limited exceptions like American Gold Eagles). A dealer who tries to steer you toward non-eligible “collectible” coins for an IRA, or who is unclear on this distinction, is either inexperienced or incentivized to sell you higher-margin products regardless of eligibility.

7. How Long They’ve Been in Business

This isn’t disqualifying on its own, since every company was new once, but longevity through both bull and bear gold markets is a meaningful signal. A company that’s operated for 10–20+ years has had to keep customers satisfied across very different market conditions.

Red Flags That Should End the Conversation

• Guarantees of a specific investment return
• Claims that gold “can’t lose value” or is “risk-free”
• Pressure to move your entire retirement account into metals
• Refusal to put fees in writing
• No verifiable BBB or BCA presence at all

A Simple Pre-Call Checklist

Before you call any Gold IRA company, write down these questions:

• What is your minimum investment?
• What are your exact setup, annual, and storage fees?
• What percentage markup over spot price do you charge?
• Which custodian and depository do you use?
• What is your buyback policy, in writing?
• Can you send me your fee schedule in writing before I provide personal information?

If a company answers all six clearly and without pressure, it has cleared the first, and most important, hurdle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a Gold IRA company the same as a custodian?

No. The dealer sells you the metal and usually helps coordinate the paperwork, but a separate, IRS-approved custodian actually administers the IRA account, and a separate depository stores the physical metal.

Are all Gold IRA companies regulated the same way?

No. There’s no single regulator overseeing “Gold IRA companies” as a category the way there is for broker-dealers. This is exactly why BBB history, custodian transparency, and fee disclosure matter so much, they’re your best available signals in the absence of uniform regulation.

How much should I expect to pay in total fees?

This varies widely by company and account size, but expect setup fees in the $50–$100 range, annual fees in the $75–$150 range, plus storage fees, on top of whatever markup applies to the metal itself. Always ask for the full, all-in number before committing.

Should I ever pay for a Gold IRA entirely over the phone without written documentation?

No. Any reputable dealer will provide written fee schedules and account documentation before you finalize a purchase or rollover.

Next Step

Once you know what to look for, the next step is comparing specific companies side by side. See our Best Gold IRA Companies Compared guide for a breakdown of minimums, fees, and BBB ratings across the industry’s most established providers.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Consult a licensed financial advisor before making retirement account decisions.